Showing posts with label review by Rose Green. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review by Rose Green. Show all posts

The Star of Kazan by Eva Ibbotson




This book is Eva Ibbotson's love song to her native city, and for anyone who's ever loved anything Germanic, this book is for you.


Even though she started life as a foundling, 12-year-old Annika has the best life ever. It's 1909, and she lives with Ellie, the cook for three sibling professors in Vienna; Sigrid, another servant; and of course the three professors, who have become sort of uncles and aunt to her. She is friends with everyone on the street, from the huge Bodek family (all boys; Stefan is her age) to the florist. She even lives within walking distance of the famous Vienna Riding School. Annika's world is one of rich sights, delicious food, and most of all, love and security. And then, everything changes when a gracious noblewoman woman shows up to claim Annika has her long lost daughter, and Annika leaves her beloved Vienna for a new life northern Germany.


But Großpriesnetz isn't quite what she expected (peasants do not live in cold houses; they have cook stoves to keep them warm, she realizes). She may be a noble now, but the food is meager, needed clothing comes seldom, and the house is bare and freezing. The von Tannenbergs have little left but their pride. Unfortunately, their trials don't make them into particularly nice people. If Annika is bent on seeing the best in her family, the reader has no illusions about what they are really like. And slowly, even Annika must admit that something is not right.


In some ways the book reminds me of A Little Princess, but there's a lot more to it. A mystery, gypsies, Lippizzaner horses, a cookbook, fabulous jewels, a dramatic rescue involving a harp case, and a love of Austria to make even someone who's never been there feel just a little bit homesick.


Recommended age: 10 and up


Review by Rose Green, occasional contributor

Things Not Seen by Andrew Clements



Things start to go wrong for fifteen-year-old Bobby Phillips the day he wakes up and finds he’s invisible. When his parents, the only ones who know his secret, are involved in a car accident and need a hospital stay, Bobby has a double problem: find a way to become visible again, and do it before the state authorities, who are worried about him being home alone, find out. Can Bobby and his blind friend-turning-girlfriend Alicia make him visible again before the nosy social worker causes problems for his parents?

One of the great things about this book is its matter-of-factness. Sure, you can’t really turn invisible, but Clements makes this sound completely reasonable. Another strength is its main character. Bobby is the kind of guy you’d love to have for a friend. He’s positive and determined and good at taking risks to do things that are important. And so is Alicia. This book won the first ALA Schneider award in 2004. I know the Schneider award has to do with characters with disabilities (Rules is the most recent winner), but I honestly had to stop and think why this book dealt with disabilities. It took me a minute before I caught on. Alicia is blind. But it’s not a book about disabilities, which is what makes it so refreshing. It’s people who happen to have “disabilities” doing cool stuff.

Things Not Seen is followed by a sequel, Things Hoped For. Let’s hope Mr. Clements continues writing YA. He's certainly hooked this YA reader!


Posted by Rose Green